JOBS BY STATE | Every state lost jobs. CA, NY, TX lost the most.

This map is interactive at the source (BLS).

May 22, 2020—In April 2020, jobs (nonfarm payroll employment) decreased in every one of the 50 states and in the District of Columbia.

The most-affected states were primarily ones with more population and more density.

States with Largest Job Losses

The three states with the largest job declines were California, New York and Texas.

California lost 2.34 million jobs, New York lost 1.83 million (more precisely, 1,827,300 net nonfarm payroll jobs) and Texas lost 1.30 million.

The three states with the largest percentage loss of jobs were Michigan, Vermont and New York. Michigan lost 22.8 percent of its jobs. Vermont lost 19.6 percent and New York lost 18.8 percent. See Tables E and 3 of the Bureau of Labor Statistics release this morning.

Which Sectors Lost the Most Jobs in New York State?

The hardest-hit industry sector in New York was Leisure and Hospitality, which lost, between March and April 2020, 548,500 jobs, or 64.1 percent of all of its payroll jobs in New York State. This of course reflects Governor Andrew Cuomo's well-advised shutdown order.  Health care workers and teachers jobs declined by much less, only 10.9 percent. Financial and information services, and government, appear to have maintained their staffing, presumably through use of the Internet.

Industry	March	April	Decline	Percent decline
Mining and Logging	4.8	4.8	0.0	0.0
Construction	383.8	234.1	149.7	39.0
Manufacturing	435.9	355.3	80.6	18.5
Trade, Transport, Utilities	1,513.0	1181.5	331.5	21.9
Information	275.8	267.5	8.3	3.0
Financial Activities	700.5	685.6	14.9	2.1
Professional and Biz Svces	1,373.1	1178.3	194.8	14.2
Educational, Health Svces	2,182.1	1944.9	237.2	10.9
Leisure and Hospitality	855.9	307.4	548.5	64.1
Other Services	411.6	291.1	120.5	29.3
Government	1,500.1	1438.9	61.2	4.1
Total	9,636.6	7,889.4	1,747.2	18.1

Source: BLS data (first two columns), computations (second two columns) by CityEconomist. The BLS payroll data by state are not seasonally adjusted.

Over the past twelve months (April 2019 to April 2020), New York lost 1,904,900 payroll jobs. In April, New York’s private sector lost 1,764,600 private payroll jobs compared with March, and over the past twelve months it lost 1,845,700 private payroll jobs.

Trajectories by State

Imperial College of London has published a tracking report for each U.S. state that shows how the trajectory of outbreaks diverges. At the time of release, 24 states, mostly in the midwest and south, had “uncontrolled” outbreaks, meaning the reproduction (infection) rate of the virus was above 1.

Unemployment by State

The unemployment rate in April rose to the highest level in Nevada, 28.2 percent, followed by Michigan, 22.7 percent, and Hawaii, 22.3 percent. The rates, which are seasonally adjusted, set new series highs in 43 states. All state series begin in 1976. The information is from the Bureau of Labor Statistics this morning, along with an interactive map of state unemployment rates.

Unemployment rates in Hawaii and Nevada exceeded their previous series highs by more than 10.0 percentage points each. Connecticut had the lowest unemployment rate, 7.9 percent. All together, 27 states and the District of Columbia had unemployment rates lower than the national average of 14.7 percent and 10 states had higher rates (the other 13 state rates were not significantly different from that of the nation). This information is in Tables A, B and 1 of the BLS release.

In April, the largest unemployment rate increases occurred in Nevada (+21.3 percentage points), Hawaii (+19.9 points), and Michigan (+18.4 points). Rates rose over the month by at least 10.0 percentage points in an additional 17 states. The smallest over-the-month jobless rate increases occurred in Nebraska (+4.3 percentage points) and Connecticut (+4.5 points). This information is from Table C in the BLS release.

The largest unemployment rate increases from April 2019 occurred in Nevada (+24.2 percentage points) and Hawaii (+19.6 points), and Michigan (+18.4 points). Another 21 states experienced increases of 10.0 points or more. The smallest over-the-year rate increases occurred in Connecticut (+4.2 percentage points) and Minnesota (+4.9 points). See Table D in the BLS release.

New York's unemployment rate rose by 10.4 percentage points to 14.5 percent in April. New York’s labor force participation rate fell to 58.3 percent in April from 60.2 percent in March.